Kentucky's 7 Best Bagel Shops to Visit in 2024!

You’re ready to start off your day. You’ve got a cup of coffee in one hand and a perfectly-toasted bagel spread with cream cheese or butter. What could be better? In Kentucky, you’ll find a variety of bagel shops serving up flavors and combinations you won’t find anywhere else. Discover Kentucky's 7 best bagel shops to visit in 2024, from bagels topped with cream cheese and lox to hearty bagel sandwiches.

Great Bagel, Lexington, KY

Bagels at Great Bagel are nothing short of spectacular. Like several traditional bagel shops, you can order an everything, onion, cinnamon raisin, whole wheat, rye or any other bagel your heart desires. They make bagels the way you like as well, toasted or not. Their specialty bagels are where it’s at though, so make sure to order from the menu if it’s your first visit to one of the best bagel shops in Kentucky. 

Stella’s Kentucky Deli, Lexington, KY

The best bagel and lox in Kentucky can be found at Stella’s Kentucky Deli. If you like toasted bagels with cream cheese, smoked salmon, red onions and capers look no further. Stella’s will hook you up with the most delicious bagel and lox you will find outside of Brooklyn Heights. They also have plenty of other bagel options to choose from, and soups to pair with your selection that will curb your enthusiasm for any other bagel. 

Third Street Stuff, Lexington, KY

Third Street Stuff in Lexington is a premier spot to get a bagel and coffee. They always have multiple bagels waiting to be found by your taste buds. Not to mention, Third Street Stuff, is one of the coolest little coffee shops in Kentucky. The environment and the bagels here are plentiful. Come check out Third Street Stuff today for your very own bagel and fresh cup of java.

Heitzman Bakery, Louisville, KY

Heitzman Bakery in Louisville, Kentucky, has been serving the community for over 120 years. They are one of the oldest bakeries in the state. Perfected in their bakery, Heitzman bagels are a well, sought-after favorite among Louisville natives. There is also a good chance that if you find another bagel in the city, they have used Heitzman as their bakers for years. 

Nancy’s Bagels, Newport, KY

Opening its doors in 2008, Nancy’s Bagels has always maintained a notable presence in Northern Kentucky. Nancy Haner Grantz created this location in Newport, Kentucky, aside from her original location in Louisville, Kentucky. She wanted to bring to her hometown (Newport) the amazing bagels she has been making in Louisville for several years. With bagel options such as sesame, poppy and pumpernickel–Nancy’s Bagels has a bit of everything for anyone.

Native Bagel Company, Berea, KY

Native Bagel Company is the most economical bagel shop you will find in the state. Their prices on bagels and cream cheese are overwhelmingly cheap considering what you get for your money. A garlic bagel with rosemary honey cream cheese can be yours for the low price of $3. 

Share your favorites!
Kentucky Search
Find Bagel Shops Near You
Select a Kentucky town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Anderson County
Caldwell County
Clark County
Clinton County
Fayette County
Franklin County
Fulton County
Harrison County
Hickman County
Nicholas County
Robertson County
Simpson County
Trimble County
Wayne County
Woodford County